ACL348: Development in American Poetry
Instructor: Dr. Seda Şen Moodle Password: Poetry2026
📚 Study Material Overview
This study material provides a comprehensive overview of significant poetic movements in 19th-century Europe and their influence (or lack thereof) on American poetry. It delves into the characteristics of the American Genteel Tradition, its eventual decline, and the emergence of pioneering American poets like Edwin Arlington Robinson and Carl Sandburg, who began to forge new paths in American verse.
📝 Source Information: This study guide has been compiled and organized from lecture notes (PDF/PowerPoint slides) and an audio transcript provided for the ACL348 course.
1. Nineteenth-Century European Poetic Movements 🌍
The 19th century was a dynamic period for poetry in Europe, marked by a succession of movements that reacted to and built upon each other.
1.1. Romanticism (Late 18th Century – Mid-19th Century)
- Origins: Began in Germany and England, spreading across Europe.
- Key Themes: Emotion, nature, individualism, imagination, the supernatural, nationalism.
- Style: Lyrical poetry, free expression, vivid imagery, personal and subjective experiences.
- Major Poets: William Wordsworth, Samuel Taylor Coleridge, Lord Byron, Percy Bysshe Shelley, John Keats.
1.2. Parnassianism (1850s – 1890s, France and Beyond)
- Origins: A reaction against the emotional excesses of Romanticism, associated with the journal Le Parnasse Contemporain.
- Key Themes: Art for art’s sake, detachment, beauty in form and precision, rejection of sentimentality.
- Style: Strict form, objective tone, classical influences.
- Major Poets: Théophile Gautier, Charles Leconte de Lisle (popular mainly in France, Italy, and Spain).
1.3. Symbolism (Late 19th Century, 1870s – 1900s, France and Belgium)
- Origins: Developed in France as a response to Parnassianism and Realism, emphasizing mysticism and suggestion over direct meaning.
- Key Themes: Dreams, the subconscious, spirituality, sensory experiences, music in poetry.
- Style: Ambiguity, free verse, synesthetic imagery (mixing senses), musicality.
- Major Poets: Charles Baudelaire (Les Fleurs du mal), Paul Verlaine, Arthur Rimbaud, Stéphane Mallarmé.
1.4. Pre-Raphaelitism (Mid-to-Late 19th Century, England)
- Origins: Developed by the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood, rejecting modern industrialization and emphasizing medieval and Renaissance aesthetics.
- Key Themes: Medievalism, beauty, sensuality, nature, spirituality, moral narratives.
- Style: Lush imagery, elaborate descriptions, archaic language.
- Major Poets: Dante Gabriel Rossetti, Christina Rossetti, Algernon Charles Swinburne, William Morris.
1.5. Decadent Movement (Late 19th Century, 1880s – 1890s, France & England)
- Origins: An extension of Symbolism, focusing on artifice, sensual pleasure, and moral decline.
- Key Themes: Aestheticism, hedonism, the exotic, detachment from morality, rebellion against realism.
- Style: Ornate, experimental, rich in metaphor and symbolism.
- Major Poets: Charles Baudelaire, Oscar Wilde, Ernest Dowson, Arthur Symons.
1.6. Russian Realist & Early Symbolist Poetry (Mid-to-Late 19th Century, Russia)
- Origins: A unique fusion of Romanticism, nationalism, and realism, evolving into Symbolism.
- Key Themes: Social criticism, history, existential questions, mysticism.
- Style: A blend of lyrical beauty and political engagement, moving towards Symbolist abstraction.
- Major Poets: Alexander Pushkin.
📊 Summary Table of European Poetic Movements
| Movement | Key Themes | Style | | :--------------------------- | :--------------------------------------------- | :----------------------------------------- | | Romanticism | Emotion, nature, imagination | Lyrical, personal, dramatic | | Parnassianism | Formal beauty, detachment | Strict form, precise diction | | Symbolism | Dreams, spirituality, ambiguity | Free verse, musicality | | Pre-Raphaelitism | Medievalism, beauty, spirituality | Detailed, ornate, rich imagery | | Decadence | Hedonism, aestheticism, rebellion | Sensual, experimental | | Russian Realism & Early Symbolism | History, existentialism, mysticism | Political, moving toward abstraction |
2. The American Genteel Tradition and its Decline 🇺🇸
While European poets were actively experimenting with form and subject matter, American poets remained somewhat isolated from these cutting-edge discussions. They largely valued earlier British Romantic poetry, leading to the development of the Genteel Tradition.
2.1. Definition and Context
- Period: Roughly 1865–1915 (late 19th to early 20th century).
- Influences: British Romanticism and Neoclassicism.
- Core Values: Tied to American middle-class respectability, moral values, and restraint.
- Stance: Upheld traditional poetic forms and themes, rejecting the realism and experimentation that would characterize Modernism.
2.2. Characteristics of Genteel Poetry ✅
- Formalism and Traditionalism:
- Adherence to strict meter, rhyme schemes, and classical forms (sonnets, odes, elegies).
- Avoidance of free verse or experimental structures.
- Emphasis on polished, refined language.
- Moral Didacticism:
- Poetry was expected to uplift, instruct, and reflect high moral values.
- Themes: Duty, virtue, patriotism, family, faith.
- Avoided controversial topics like industrialization, urban decay, racial tensions, or sexuality.
- Sentimentality and Idealization:
- Often nostalgic, romanticizing the past, rural life, and genteel society.
- Common themes: Death, love, spirituality, often presented in an overly sentimental manner.
- Avoidance of Harsh Realities:
- Shunned realism and naturalism, avoiding depictions of poverty, war, and racial struggles.
- ⚠️ Contrast: This set them apart from Walt Whitman, Emily Dickinson, and later Modernists who confronted modern life's complexities.
- Eurocentric Influence:
- Followed European poetic traditions, particularly British Romantic and Victorian poets (e.g., Alfred, Lord Tennyson, John Keats).
- Looked to Greek and Roman classical literature as models of refinement.
2.3. Poets and Critics Who Favored Genteel Poetry
- Henry Wadsworth Longfellow: Famous for The Song of Hiawatha and Paul Revere’s Ride, known for polished, melodic verse.
- James Russell Lowell: Poet and critic who upheld genteel values.
- Oliver Wendell Holmes Sr.: Known for light verse, wit, and moralistic themes.
- John Greenleaf Whittier: Quaker poet, remembered for sentimental, religious, and abolitionist poetry.
2.4. Decline and Legacy 📉
- By the early 20th century, the Genteel Tradition was criticized as outdated and disconnected from modern life.
- Modernist Rejection: Poets like Ezra Pound and T.S. Eliot rejected its rigid moralism and sentimentality, favoring realism, complexity, and free verse.
- Critical Scrutiny: Critics like H.L. Mencken and George Santayana mocked its conservative approach.
- Emergence of New Voices: The rise of Whitman’s influence, the Harlem Renaissance, and Modernist experimentation (1910s-1920s) replaced genteel poetry with more diverse and dynamic voices.
- Legacy: Despite obsolescence, it helped establish poetry as an important part of American cultural life. Its emphasis on formal elegance influenced some later poets (e.g., New Formalists).
3. Leaving the Genteel Tradition Behind: Early Modern American Poets 💡
The period between 1890 and 1912 saw a shift in American poetry, with new tendencies emerging that challenged the Genteel Tradition. Among these were "Vagabond Poetry," "Poetry of Socialist Protest," and the "Beginnings of Modern American Poetry." Edwin Arlington Robinson and Carl Sandburg were pivotal figures in this transition, moving American poetry towards a more realistic and diverse expression.
3.1. Edwin Arlington Robinson (1869–1935)
Robinson's life was marked by hardship, including family financial collapse, addiction within his family, and his own struggles with chronic pain and alcoholism. Despite these challenges, and initial lack of interest from contemporaries, his work eventually gained recognition, notably from Theodore Roosevelt. He never married and dedicated his later life to writing.
3.1.1. "Richard Cory" (1897) 📖
This poem is a classic example of Robinson's exploration of inner turmoil beneath a polished exterior.
- Themes:
- Appearance vs. Reality: Richard Cory appears perfect – wealthy, refined, admired by all. The townspeople see him as the epitome of success.
- Societal Perception: The poem highlights how external appearances can be deceiving and how society often idealizes wealth and status.
- Hidden Suffering: Despite his seemingly perfect life, Cory harbors deep, unseen despair, leading to his tragic suicide.
- Irony of Desire: The townspeople "wish that we were in his place," unaware of the profound unhappiness that plagues him.
- Style:
- Traditional Form: Written in quatrains (four-line stanzas) with an ABAB rhyme scheme, reflecting a formal structure that contrasts with the shocking content.
- Narrative: Tells a concise story, building up the image of an ideal man before the abrupt, tragic ending.
- Irony: The stark contrast between Cory's public image and his private despair creates powerful dramatic irony.
- Example:
"And he was rich—yes, richer than a king— / And admirably schooled in every grace: / In fine, we thought that he was everything / To make us wish that we were in his place. / So on we worked, and waited for the light, / And went without the meat, and cursed the bread; / And Richard Cory, one calm summer night, / Went home and put a bullet through his head."
3.1.2. "Miniver Cheevy" (1910) 📖
This poem presents a character consumed by nostalgia and a longing for a bygone era, unable to cope with his present reality.
- Themes:
- Nostalgia and Escapism: Miniver Cheevy yearns for the "days of old" – medieval times, ancient Greece – and despises his contemporary world.
- Disillusionment: He is deeply unhappy with the "commonplace" and the lack of "Romance" in his life.
- Inaction and Inability to Adapt: Instead of engaging with his present, he "dreamed, and rested from his labors," ultimately succumbing to drinking as a coping mechanism.
- Irony of Self-Pity: He "wept that he was ever born" and "coughed, and called it fate," but his suffering is largely self-imposed through his refusal to accept reality.
- Style:
- Traditional Form: Also uses quatrains with an ABAB rhyme scheme, creating a somewhat whimsical tone that underscores Miniver's detachment.
- Character Study: The poem is a vivid portrait of a specific type of individual, a dreamer out of sync with his time.
- Humor and Pathos: Robinson blends a sense of gentle mockery with an underlying sympathy for Miniver's plight.
- Example:
"Miniver sighed for what was not, / And dreamed, and rested from his labors; / He dreamed of Thebes and Camelot, / And Priam’s neighbors. / Miniver mourned the ripe renown / That made so many a name so fragrant; / He mourned Romance, now on the town, / And Art, a vagrant."
3.2. Carl Sandburg (1878–1967)
Born to Swedish immigrants in Illinois, Sandburg's early life was marked by manual labor and a lack of formal education. His experiences shaped his democratic, working-class sensibility. He became a journalist and a social activist, and his poetry, published in Poetry Magazine, brought a new, robust voice to American literature.
3.2.1. "Chicago" (1914) 📖
This poem is a powerful ode to the industrial city, embracing its rough vitality and acknowledging its flaws.
- Themes:
- Urban Realism: Sandburg confronts the harsh realities of city life – wickedness, crime, poverty – but also celebrates its strength and energy.
- Industrial Power: The city is personified as a "Hog Butcher," "Tool Maker," "Stacker of Wheat," highlighting its role in American industry.
- Paradox of the City: It is "wicked" and "brutal" yet also "proud to be alive and coarse and strong and cunning."
- Pride in the Working Class: The poem champions the laborers and the raw, unrefined spirit of the city.
- Style:
- Free Verse: A radical departure from traditional forms, allowing for a natural, conversational rhythm that mimics speech.
- Direct Address: The speaker directly addresses the city, creating an intimate yet grand tone.
- Personification: Chicago is given human qualities ("City of the Big Shoulders," "laughing with white teeth").
- Colloquial Language: Uses everyday language, reflecting the common man's experience.
- Cataloging: Lists the city's attributes and industries, building a comprehensive image.
- Example:
"Hog Butcher for the World, / Tool Maker, Stacker of Wheat, / Player with Railroads and the Nation's Freight Handler; / Stormy, husky, brawling, / City of the Big Shoulders: / They tell me you are wicked and I believe them, for I have seen your painted women under the gas lamps luring the farm boys."
3.2.2. "Fog" (1916) 📖
A short, evocative poem that captures a fleeting natural phenomenon with a simple, yet profound, metaphor.
- Themes:
- Nature in the Urban Landscape: Shows how natural elements can quietly intrude upon and transform the city.
- Brevity and Transience: The fog's arrival and departure are quick and silent, emphasizing the fleeting nature of such moments.
- Quiet Observation: The poem encourages a moment of stillness and appreciation for subtle beauty.
- Style:
- Free Verse: Again, Sandburg uses free verse to allow the poem to flow naturally, mirroring the movement of the fog.
- Metaphor: The central metaphor compares the fog to a cat, giving it animalistic qualities ("little cat feet," "sits looking," "silent haunches").
- Imagery: Creates a strong visual and sensory experience with minimal words.
- Conciseness: The poem's brevity makes its impact more potent.
- Example:
"The fog comes / on little cat feet. / It sits looking / over harbor and city / on silent haunches / and then moves on."
Conclusion 🏁
The 19th century was a period of significant poetic evolution, both in Europe with its diverse movements from Romanticism to Decadence, and in America, where the Genteel Tradition initially held sway. However, as the 20th century approached, American poetry began to shed its conservative skin, embracing realism, social commentary, and innovative forms through the pioneering works of poets like Edwin Arlington Robinson and Carl Sandburg. Their contributions marked a crucial step in the development of a distinctively modern American poetic voice.








